I come from a book loving family. My mom is a librarian, my sister works in publishing, and my Dad, a life-long bibliophile, has been a writer of many sermons and one book. Me, I write internet content. And more importantly, I read.
Which makes it funny, in a way, that for all the aspects of unschooling that I question and struggle to wrap my mind around, reading isn't one of them. Many parents, grandparents, and concerned strangers seem convinced that children will never learn to read unless forced to do so.
Personally, I'm 99% certain that my kids will learn to read. Maybe not at three, maybe not at five (though I wouldn't be surprised), but eventually - when they have a reason to. To me, the interesting thing is not that unschooling kids learn to read (they do, seemingly without fail), but how it happens. In some stories I've heard, they ask for help when they want to be able to enjoy books more independently. In others, they teach themselves, maybe using computer games or other technology. In our house, we've already seen both of these things, as River learned the alphabet from videos and games that he likes, and has since started to ask about words and letters. Occasionally, though, it seems that kids wait long enough to learn reading by osmosis, in almost the same way that they learn to talk. Parents of older children, perhaps concerned that they haven't shown any interest yet, will suddenly discover them reading chapter books. How did they learn to do that?
Interestingly, some research shows that the phonics method, taught in schools and homes all over the world, isn't necessarily the most efficient way to read. Apparently hearing the sound of words while you read, as most of us do, can slow us down to about a third of our potential reading and comprehension speed. It's possible to reverse this habit by using speed reading training tools like those found at spreeder, but you know who can do it faster automatically? Self-taught readers.
Other research on reading shows that the single biggest factor influencing whether kids grow up to be book lovers is not how or when they learn to read, but whether they see their parents reading - they learn this habit by example. That's a major factor, and one of the few in the control of parents. If it's true then my kids should be in good shape, reading-wise. Of course, it's not a foolproof guarantee; they may learn to enjoy other pursuits more and read only when necessary, regardless of anything I might do or not do.
They will learn to read, though, I'm almost sure of it. On the off chance, that other 1% or .5% or .1% chance that they don't find it worth doing eventually, I'm almost certain that I'll be even more impressed with the sheer fortitude it takes to make and live with such an interesting and unusual decision. It would be a different life, more immediate and present maybe, but also requiring more human interactions, a wonderful memory, and a good sense of humor to deal with the challenges. It sounds kind of exciting, actually.
Amusingly, I was a 'late' reader. I didn't really get going till the end of first grade which was considered pretty ridiculous in the school I was in. (A tiny super yuppie school in a remote part of the Santa Cruz mountains. There were 138 kids in the school at maximum enrollment when it was k-12. By the time I went it was k-8 and they phased out 7th and 8th grade about two years later because the classes were too small.)
ReplyDeleteThey wanted to hold me back because I just wasn't smart enough. By the time they did standardized testing in the middle of second grade (my mother refused to hold me back) I was reading at 10th grade level. So much for not being smart enough. :P
I have zero fear about our kids not reading. I'm an obsessive compulsive reader and I really just can't imagine my kids not reading as a survival trait for dealing with me. :) I am managing to talk Noah into feeling more secure about the idea of unschooling but he is still freaked out about maths. Enh, it'll work out somehow. :D
Thanks for sharing this.
ReplyDeleteDid you see the article about the effect of book-filled childhoods on intelligence?
http://www.salon.com/books/laura_miller/2010/06/02/summer_book_giveaway/index.html
Also, I think you'd enjoy the short surreal book "How I Became a Nun" by César Aira, which features a kid refusing to learn to read except on his own terms. Actually he refuses to participate in any adult authority or reality except on his own terms, including rejecting assumed gender roles.
I used "Rev It Up Reading" as a speed reading tool. I kind of wish I had done it while in school but it is helping me take on all kinds of technical reading and even some pleasure reading now and again which I never had time for before. Check it out at www.revitupreading.com .
ReplyDelete:-) It's hard to not learn to read...even with something like dyslexia (there are plenty of those stories from unschoolers as well)...you might not learn to read when 'everybody' think you *should*, but you'll learn to read when it's important enough to you.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure you read my post about Elijah learning to read or me realizing that he could read, but in case you didn't http://www.naturalattachment.com/wordpress/2008/12/27/we-can-read/
Wow it's great to meet book and reading lovers. I am a reading advocate too. Bought my daughter's first books when I was 2 months pregnant. Now I have a full bookcase of books for my 4-year old.
ReplyDeleteWe love reading!